Positive Feedback:

Overall, Style 1 is warmer and matches the restaurant “brand” more

Style 1 has a homier feel

Style 1 matches Broadway/Downtown nightlife location better

Adjectives on Style 1 were really good and matched what the restaurant represents

Script typeface was good

Constructive Feedback:

On Style 1, maybe subhead typeface can be more bold

Style 2 doesn’t match restaurant brand as well as Style 1

Style 2 is too modern and clean for the restaurant feel

Think about designing with the downtown location (it's the only location - more authentic and homey) and homemade pasta sell in mind

Style 2 doesn’t consider the downtown lifestyle as much either